"Truly a great dining experience for my birthday 🤍 • Had a delicious corner burger and hands down the best chocolate cake ever • I prefer more pepper, so I seasoned my patty a bit more, but overall a very solid meal • Fries were cooked perfectly • The staff surprised me with their famous 24-layer cake, and it truly lives up to the hype — rich, decadent, and addicting 🍫🎂 • Reserved online a day in advance, which I highly recommend as the place gets busy • Staff were attentive and very kind; the manager was especially accommodating • Truly appreciated their sweet gesture that made my day extra beautiful • Clean dining area and the perfect classic NYC diner experience 💫"

"My adult child friend from high school wanted to take my daughter to a brunch on her birthday. I never been to this location, so a tagged along. There was a wait time when with a reservation. However, once we were seated, the server was fast. The food was delivered quickly and was delicious. The diner has a menu that is like a text book with many options. The plus was that they offer unlimited mimosa which my child and her friend enjoyed. The atmosphere is a pure New York vibe. I will definitely returned."

"Absolutely loved this place! The breakfast options are excellent and everything tastes fresh and delicious. There is usually a long queue but it moves quickly and the service was efficient even after being jam packed. We tried their burgers (veg & non-veg), pasta, and pancakes — each dish was flavorful and perfectly cooked. Good part, they have options for vegetarians too. The portions are generous and definitely filling. Highly recommend for anyone looking for a hearty and satisfying meal! The best meal I had in my whole NY trip ❤️"

"We came across Carnegie Diner while in New York this past weekend during a winter storm. Literally a few steps from the Stanford hotel. Delicious breakfast options and good service. Somewhat expensive but hey, we are on vacation mode. In all seriousness, definitely recommend this diner. Good location, great breakfast options."

"Had a deliciously juicy burger and the fries were crispy and fresh as well! The side salad was also very refreshing. The service was excellent and pretty quick. We’ve known that this place is known for their layered chocolate cake. It was very moist but on the sweeter and rich side. If you enjoy that type of dessert you’ll really love this option. Overall, a great first experience."