"The gelato here is amazing!!! One of the workers, Steve, is honestly such a breath of fresh air. His service is unreal and all the gelato options are amazing. If you want the best combo, just ask him, he'll put together such fantastic combos. The espresso gelato+dark chocolate and milk chocolate+hazelnut are the best together! Thanks Steve ❤️"

"Review – Gelateria Gentile (NYC) Gelateria Gentile offers really, really good ice cream, made with high-quality raw ingredients that you can truly taste in every bite. The texture is smooth and creamy, and the flavors feel authentic and well-balanced —not overly sweet, just right. They don’t have a huge variety of flavors, but the ones they do offer are excellent —you can tell they focus on quality over quantity. In addition to gelato, they also serve small bites and coffee, making it a nice spot to stop for an afternoon treat. 📍 Conclusion: Gelateria Gentile is a must-visit for gelato lovers looking for genuine flavor and artisanal quality. Limited selection, but everything they serve is top-notch. ⭐ Overall rating: 9/10 🍨 Best: the quality of the ingredients and texture. 🍫 Worst: not many flavor options. 💸 Price: fair for the quality."

"Gelateria Gentile is a soft reminder that legacy is something you earn, not something you market. While most of this city is obsessed with the latest "viral" dessert trend, this place is a historic Italian institution that has been refining family recipes since 1880. When you’ve been perfecting a craft for over 140 years…you don't need to shout to be heard. If you can’t make it to Florence, Italy, then stop by Gentile for some truly fantastic, authentic Italian gelato that carries the weight of tradition in every scoop."

"Came here with my father and hands down some of the best Gelato we’ve ever had! Everything about this place absolutely blew us away. The atmosphere was very cozy and comfy and really helped give off a very comfortable vibe, extremely well decorated! My father ended up getting Pistachio and Vanilla and he thoroughly enjoyed both flavors. He told me that the pistachio really tasted strong and felt like they were made from the real deal rather than the usual artificial flavoring we’re used to. Meanwhile I was less sure about what flavor to get but thankfully the staff were very kind and recommended me some great flavors! I ended up getting the Wild Berries and Dark Chocolate flavor, as recommended by the staff (thanks for that!) and it absolutely delivered. Great recommendation honestly, it was delicious! The chocolate was rich and deep and the wild berries were sweet and tangy and left me wanting more. What great flavor combos! I also just got to take a second to absolutely rave on about the staff, genuinely some of the nicest most friendly people I’ve met my entire stay in New York! They were so kind and funny, giving good ice cream advice and making everything just a great vibe! TLDR, if you’re in the area and looking for a cold sweet treat, I would HIGHLY recommend checking this place out!"

"Cioccolato is very rich, I paired with coconut, it is a high quality gelato and the staff is very friendly 💛. They also have italian shave ice and coffee options. They have a good assortment of pastries too, the corona with pecans is really tasty."