"My daughter insisted that this was a must stop while we were visiting NYC. Granted, I spent the earlier half of my life in the area, but my daughters haven’t and they saw a TikTok influencer rave about it, so take that for what it’s worth. But I will say it was a very pleasant experience although the line tends to get long, it moves very quickly, and the staff are exceptionally kind and efficient. The bagels were delicious. As always- there is nothing like a bagel from NY/NJ. I miss them! If you do decide to make this a stop, it will not disappoint."

"Unbelievable bagels and great service! I stopped by Liberty Bagels Midtown during a mother–daughter weekend in NYC, and it did not disappoint! It’s an easy walk from 5th Avenue, and even though the line forms outside, it moves quickly thanks to the nice gentleman managing the flow of traffic. Orders are handled super efficiently—pickups are brought right to the door for fast access. Inside there’s a small standing bar, and outside you’ll find a few tables on the patio if you want to enjoy your food there. The staff was friendly, the service was quick, and the food was incredible. I had a blueberry bagel with egg, sausage, and cheese—honestly one of the best bagels I’ve ever had. And don’t skip the hash browns—they’re worth it! Highly recommend this spot for anyone craving a true New York bagel experience."

"Go for the Rainbow bagel. You know you want to. We did and enjoyed it along with some other bagel options. Bonus: you can also get a red white and blue Liberty bagel. Plenty of cream cheese choices too. The crowds were wild but manageable. Started outside and they let you in one group at a time. Then you wait inside in a split line to order. Then you wait again in the pickup line once it’s ready. Whole process took about 20 min or so. Limited seating/standing outside. Share if you need to or take to go. Must try spot if in the area."

"If you know me well, you’re probably aware that I don’t consider myself a Foodie Expert by any means. However, let me tell you, my experience at the Liberty Bagel shop in the vibrant heart of New York City was truly unforgettable and absolutely worth sharing! This little gem of a place, tucked away amidst the bustling streets, serves up what I can confidently declare to be the very best bagels I have ever tasted in my life. Among the delightful options available, I decided to indulge in the Bella Nova, an incredible creation that absolutely blew my taste buds away, all nestled within a perfectly baked salt bagel that added the ideal hint of savory goodness. Each bite was a delightful explosion of flavor that left me craving more!"

"Liberty Bagels Midtown is absolute chaos in the best possible way. Place was packed—standing room only—like a bagel-themed subway car at rush hour. But honestly? Worth it. The bagels are so good they should come with a warning label. Chewy, fresh, and clearly the reason everyone in Midtown decided to be in the same square footage at the same time. Staff somehow kept things moving despite the crowd, which felt like an Olympic-level achievement. If you’re looking for a quiet, meditative breakfast… this ain’t it. If you want a top-tier bagel and a story to tell afterward, get in line and embrace the madness. 🥯👏"