"Liberty Bagels absolutely lived up to the hype. We ordered the highline on an everything bagel, and it was perfect, fresh, flavorful, and perfectly balanced. We also hot steakwitch on a salty bagel that was so good but the bagel was a bot too salty for me! Overall, their bagels are chewy on the inside with just the right crunch outside. Great quality, great execution, and well worth the stop."

"Amazing Bagels with tons of selections and flavors including cream cheeses. Fun and interactive choices. Staff friendly and informative. I ordered colorful rainbow bagel which tasted great and had fun look. Even have holiday bagel choices. Fast service very minimal wait. Atmosphere is fun and interactive. Best bagel i have tasted with low prices."

"We stopped in for breakfast and tried a few different bagel combinations, and everything we ordered was genuinely enjoyable. I went with the egg everything bagel with lox scallion cream cheese. The bagel itself was delicious with great flavor and a nice chew, though—as is the case with most everything bagels—the firmer exterior makes it a little harder to bite through, so the cream cheese can squish out the sides. The lox scallion spread, however, absolutely made it worth it, delivering that perfect balance of flavors you’d expect from a classic New York lox bagel sandwich. I also tried the Liberty bagel with the honey bacon sriracha cream cheese. The bagel looks great with its colorful swirl, but underneath the fun appearance it’s really just a solid, traditional New York bagel. The honey bacon sriracha cream cheese was the highlight here: a delicious mix of savory, sweet, and spicy. It definitely carries a bit of heat—similar to what you’d find in a good buffalo sauce—so be ready for a little kick. My wife ordered an egg bagel with the peanut butter Nutella cream cheese after learning they don’t toast the French toast bagel. The egg bagel was a great alternative, and the PB Nutella spread was rich, sweet, and perfect for anyone who loves a dessert-like breakfast option. The staff was efficient, friendly, and kept the line moving smoothly during the morning rush. Ordering being in the back away from the case in the front (which was narrow) helped keep the place orderly. Everyone we interacted with was helpful, happy to answer questions and offer recommendations. The shop itself is nicely decorated, with a surprising amount of seating available in the back, making it a pleasant place to relax and enjoy your meal. Overall, it was a great stop for fresh bagels, creative cream cheeses, and genuinely good service."

"I go this place once in a while to get my bagel fix as I work near the area. Their bagels are good (soft in the inside despite of it being toasted) and my go to is their Cinnamon Walnut raisin cream cheese or Maple Bacon. A low down to this place js their customer service. I guess they’re behaving this way as they’re popular and literally next to the Bull Icon of Wall Street which is a major tourist attraction. Atmosphere is average too."

"Great bagels, super chewy, lots of flavor. The variety of cream cheeses is insane! Lots of sandwich options available too. We came 3 different days and the line was always fast, the speed to get everyone through is incredible."