"We were under the impression that the cookies were made fresh. They are not. They are packaged from factory and the ingredients list is longer than im willing to read. For $25 for 6 cookies we were extremely disappointed."

"I’ve got nooo respect for a free offering for a 5 star Google review. I hateee when places do that. So the ratings are very inflated. The soft serve just didn’t quite hit. That said, “lemon merengue” is very accurate. It really tastes like that. But it kind of left a weird aftertaste and gave both us a stomach ache. For $7.50, I’d say the soft serve is just not worth it. We also got 2 cookies."

"Every time I’m in New York I have to get milk bars, cereal, ice cream! It is truly so good, there is nothing like it. The location in Nolita is a very cute walk up window with really lovely staff. The prices are reasonable, and they now have matchboxes!"

"Very clean smells amazing ! Diana was a great help and assisted me very quickly and efficiently. I got 3 cookies for 9$ better than most places in nyc"

"I first tried the cereal-flavored ice cream at this West Village spot 6 years ago and recently had it again. As someone who loves cereal flavors and often eats the fine size ones from the grocery store, I realized there's a stark difference in the creaminess and taste when it's made fresh at this place. The texture is unbelievably smooth and the flavors are so much richer. I'll definitely be stopping by whenever I'm craving it!"