"Friendly and quick service and of course the most delicious treats- I did a build-a-pint with swirl soft serve (cereal milk and cinnamon pretzel), caramel sauce, cornflake chocolate chip marshmallow cookie, and cornflake crunch/pretzel crumb. So so so delicious!"

"This is a nice location with great service, Izaiah and Katherine were both patient with me while I ordered and recommended I try the "Milk Bar Pie". Did not regret it, every human being should try it at least once in their life.🍰"

"Disgusting! Bought the birthday cake, chocolate cake, milk pie & birthday cookie. For $11 a slice I was expecting it to be incredible but it really wasn’t good. The cake tasted like a mix & the icing on the cake was just awful. It was sickeningly sweet & you could feel the gritty sugar in your mouth while eating it. You can tell they put shortening in the frosting from the waxy residue it leaves on your tongue. If you like sweet cake with real buttercream go to Magnolia’s bakery, much bigger selection, better quality & much better taste. All four of us agreed that we will never buy from Milk Bar again!"

"Milk Bar is a must-visit for any dessert lover! The cookies are warm, gooey, and packed with flavor — from classic chocolate chip to creative seasonal specials. The staff is friendly, the place smells like heaven, and every bite feels like a little celebration. Highly recommend grabbing a box (or two)!"

"First time UWS store and it was a great experience! AK was very accommodating and nice; he answered our questions with so much kindness thank you very much!! Will go again here soon!"