"We tried Schmackary’s cookies while visiting friends who absolutely raved about them and generously shared some with us. I had high expectations going in, but honestly, I’ve had better cookies. That said, it’s very possible this was because the cookies were a day old. They were a bit hard and didn’t have that fresh baked softness I usually love. It made me realize these are probably best enjoyed fresh in the store, which surprised me a bit since they also ship nationwide. With that in mind, I can see how they would be much better right after they’re baked. I’d be open to trying them again next time I’m in New York City, or San Diego since that location would be closer for me, to see how they compare when they’re fresh."

"Went on a saturday night. The Classic: texture is good but too much salt. The salt shouldn’t overpower the chocolate in my opinion. Key lime: Pretty decent, good frosting to cookie ratio, smells very strong but the key lime pie taste is mild. Earl grey lavender tea (?): Tastes just like lavender, not my favorite but I’m not big into lavender anyways lol. Cookie dough: Raw cookie dough on a baked cookie, not sure what i expected., but i personally donr like the combination together. White chocolate; very mild white chocolate flavor and kind of salty? Peanut butter: my favorite, strong peanut butter taste and great texture. The Hangover: feels like a combination that should work but just doesn’t. The chips really throw me off. 2/10 for me, fun to try once I guess but wouldn’t come back. My boyfriend also tried it and said they were the worst cookies hes ever had, he didn’t like any of them :("

"Damn these are good cookies. Particularly the ones with savoury elements like the Maple Bacon. There’s a great balance of salt and sweet and the cookies are the right level of crispy and chewy. They also stayed fresh for a couple of days while we worked our way through them!"

"We tried the classic, chocolate crunch, and a Blondie. I went for the classic, but honestly it was a little too sweet for me. My sister, on the other hand, loved her chocolate crunch cookie!"

"Freaking love this place! It’s my absolute favorite way to wrap up an evening on Broadway! They stay open late, have quick friendly service, but best of all… AMAZING SWEET TREATS!!!! Did you know they do partnerships with lots of Broadway shows?! How cool is that?? And now they serve ice cream! The funfetti ice cream sandwich is top notch. Sweet, salty, crunchy, soft, smooth, refreshing. Hits a lot of flavor magic for me. 🤤🤤🤤🍪🍪🍪"