"I couldn’t believe why someone could say anything bad about this place. Came tonight based on a recommendation from a friend. Off menu: get the bourbon sour On menu: have the best mussels I’ve ever had with bread to sop the broth The staff was so kind and genuinely accommodating. The space was small, intimate, and cozy for a winter night. Will 💯 be back often."

"Incredible space. Great drinks and the staff was lovely. Maximo made an incredible Manhattan, and the chef put together a fantastic charcuterie board. One of the best bars I’ve visited! Highly recommend. The vibe’s and aesthetic are incredible, very cozy and intimate. Staff made us feel at home. Can’t wait to come back!"

"Have been coming here for years (15 maybe?). Always a treasure. It used to be off radar, but it’s certainly well known now, so it can get quite busy. Burger is great. Grilled chicken is too. Cocktails are baller."

"Smith & Mills Tribeca is such a special spot. I’ve been here a number of times, and it never disappoints. The food is always excellent—thoughtful, flavorful, and perfectly prepared. The cocktails are fantastic too, crafted with care and creativity. The atmosphere is what really sets this place apart: cozy, intimate, and full of character, with a vibe that makes you want to stay all night. The staff is warm and attentive, making every visit feel welcoming and effortless. It’s one of those rare NYC gems that feels both timeless and unique. Highly recommend to anyone looking for a small bar with a great experience in Tribeca."

"A neighborhood favorite that never disappoints, esp for the amazing service. Our friendly barkeep Matthew took excellent care of us, sent us on our way…. And then a while later when I realized my phone was missing i ran BACK to the bar as he was closing and helped me scour the entire bar until we found it! Total hero. This type of above-and-beyond is what makes a place like this truly special."