"My family had a wonderful evening at Supper, we didn’t want it to end! Emmanuel was the most fabulous waiter. We got their tomato and mozzarella salad, chicken parm, lemon pasta, butternut squash ravioli special, with a nice bottle of Chianti, and tiramisu. Everything was truly amazing and this is our second time ordering the chicken parm. You can’t go wrong with anything here, their menu is the perfect size so they can make each dish special. I know we will be back to continue making our way through the menu and to see Emmanuel again!"

"Heard about Supper and been wanting to try, but tonight we were feeling doordash. Ordered spaghetti lemon, chicken parm, meatballs and garlic pasta. The delivery came messy and oily.... but it was probably the doordash. Or maybe because the takeout containers are kinda flimsy... they should use the more sturdy containers. The restaurant should have thrown in some bread and beans like everyone says they get. Woulda been cool. But we didnt get any. The food was very good. Better than any pasta uber eats or doordash we have gotten recently. But maybe because it is a more expensive restaurant? We have gotten a similar amount of food fro. Other places that came to around $25 less... But we feel this is worth paying extra for because the pasta was delicious, flavorful, quality and cooked well!!!!! Al dente. Not mushy. 10/10 recommend and would order again."

"Authentic Italian experience. Loved the mushroom pasta and french toast here. Drinks were nice too. The highlight was the happy faces of the servers and their kindness throughout. It just lifts up your dining experience. Note that this is a cash only establishment and they have an ATM inside."

"My friend and I stopped at Supper for brunch. Their 3 for 1 brunch cocktails was a huge selling point. First we were served nich crusty bread with a bowl of beans. The beans were seasoned and in olive oil. I don't like beans, but they looked good so I tried them and I loved them. They were delicious. I ordered the mushroom risotto, my friend had the grilled chicken breast with roasted plum tomatoes and robiola cheese. This was the best risotto I've ever had. Perfectly creamy and absolutely delicious. The grilled chicken sandwich was equally delicious. There were torrential downpours the day we visited. The staff was happy to let us hang around until it passed. Everyone was so kind and our server was great. The atmosphere was lovely too. I highly recommend you visit Supper, you won't regret it."

"I just want to say a heartfelt thank you to Jody and the entire team at Supper for giving us such a warm, welcoming, and truly family-like experience. From the moment we walked in, we felt right at home. The food was absolutely out of this world—every bite was incredible, and it’s clear how much love and care goes into every dish. As a couple visiting from Florida, our trip to the Big Apple was already something we were excited about, but our dinner at Supper truly became one of the highlights. It made our visit feel even more special and memorable. We’re so grateful for the kindness and hospitality we received, and we’re already talking about coming back. Thank you again for everything. We loved every minute of it—and we’ll definitely be back! P.S THE BEST CHICKEN PARM IN THE CITY 🏙️"