"I would rate 5 Stars for the Speakeasy setup and the look and feel of the place. But once you take away the Speakeasy concept and the Decor, it's an average Cocktail Lounge at best. Music they were playing was too techno and trendy which didn't match the ambience. Drinks were watered down but they did look cute. Overall this place and the drinks they serve are great for Instagram Reels but if that's not what you are looking for then prepared to be disappointed."

"An epic spot for all my ice cream lovers! The UES is a 2-in-1: ice cream shop in the front and speakeasy in the back! Atmosphere: You enter into a tiny ice cream shop that has pints of ice cream assembled into the shape of a door. Once you find out how to get inside, you enter into a completely different atmosphere with detailed decor ranging from old metro cards laminated into the tables or picture frames sporadically placed on the ceiling. Service: Everyone here is kind and service-oriented. Menu items: I got their I Left My Heart in Yorkville and 2nd Avenue Subway mocktails. I'm not big on drinking but love a good mocktail. Both had a tarte-like bit to them that went well with the creamy ice cream that comes with each drink. The ice cream was astounding; I loved how creamy it was and don't think I can fully describe it. I highly recommend this experience especially if you want a less crowded experience that is unique!"

"We had an amazing time during our visit to New York, and we had such a wonderful experience at this spot. The ice cream–themed façade is fun and unique, and inside you’ll find a cozy bar with just the right atmosphere. We also loved how creative the cocktail menu was. The place was also clean when we visited, which we really appreciated. Overall, a great experience and a place we’d recommend checking out!"

"excellent service from walking in the door to getting drinks, delicious drinks and presentation, unparalleled atmosphere. Highly recommend. The staff is welcoming and professional. Anthony the bartender is incredible - first time meeting him but no doubt he’s been working here for years. We will be back"

"Absolutely amazing experience. We had such a great night, and a huge part of that was thanks to the bartender, Anthony. From the moment we sat down, the energy was warm, welcoming, and fun. The drinks were exceptional—perfectly balanced, creative, and clearly made by someone who truly knows their craft. Beyond the cocktails, the bartender made us feel taken care of and set the tone for the entire evening. Attentive without hovering, friendly without being overbearing—just flawless hospitality. It honestly turned a good night into a great one. We’ll definitely be back, and we’ll be sitting at the bar again for sure."