
About Starry Night Café
Starry Night Café is a vibrant gathering spot where locally-inspired flavors and creative energy come alive. Loved by the community for its thoughtfully prepared food, including standout specials like their Polish quesadilla, this independent gem offers something you won't find anywhere else—genuine hospitality, carefully curated artwork, and the kind of warm atmosphere that makes you want to linger. With a 4.8-star rating from 80 reviews, it's clear this is where Niagara Falls comes to connect, create, and savor truly special moments.
What People Are Saying
from Google"Had the polish quesadilla special and it was just that super special, top notch goodness. Nice little cafe. It took a moment to get my order but it was so worth the wait ( I ordered there and got takeout, only hour lunch, next time I will order ahead of time) once I smelled the food that other guests ordered, I knew I was not going to be disappointed. Hidden gem, I will be back. Customer service was excellent, let me know a couple of times that food is almost ready."
"Great unique place with freshly prepared food. Love the atmosphere and the artwork."
"I don't recommend this place at all. The food was mediocre, the service was incredibly slow, and the interior is poor. I really can't think of anything nice to say, so I'll leave it at that."
"1st off, Jo Ann was a great server. Very helpful and informative. This restaurants food is very high quality and innovative. An example; Curry Butternut Squash soup with apple. Delicious. The Big Dipper sandwich was very tender and tasty. The Bread Pudding with a bourbon glaze and whipped cream topping was awesome. I could eat here everyday."
"we are from out of town and were very confused walking into this old school-like building. when we came in, wow. the service was amazing. our server was so sweet. the kitchen was a little slow but she told us it was just her and the cook here today. my husband and 3 kids and i all agreed we’d wait all day to eat this food again! it was soooooo good and such great quality. you can tell everything here is made with love and nothing rushed. our oldest said “let’s come back here next year” i said to the falls or this restaurant? he said “just for this food!” please come eat here if you’re in town!!! 10/10"
Nearby Coffee Shops in Niagara Falls