
About TOASTY SANDWICH SHOP
Welcome to Toasty Sandwich Shop, a beloved Yonkers cafe where community and quality come first. With an impressive 4.7-star rating from hundreds of satisfied guests, this independent spot has earned its reputation as a go-to destination for breakfast and more. Unlike chain coffee shops, Toasty offers that genuine, personal touch that keeps neighbors coming back—a place where you're not just another order, but part of the family.
What People Are Saying
from Google"I was looking for a place that served a good breakfast, so I searched on Google and found several places, but this one really caught my attention... so I went to this place, which I loved. It's very nice and clean, and the person who served me was very friendly. And the breakfast was delicious. I had a spectacular day, I honestly recommend it."
"Hello I am messaging you to raise awareness regarding harmful objects in the food of toasty sandwich shop. I had ordered the apple crisp chicken salad and when I got home and began eating my salad and found plastic in my food that is easy to miss/consume when you are trying to eat fast. Please be aware and check your food for hazards."
"We got the freaking French toast (swapped ham for bacon) and the snooze Am wrap. The French toast plus the bec was the perfect combo. The Am wrap with secret sauce (chipotle Mayo type sauce) was really good with the hash browns. Would definitely go back!"
"Stopped here on our way to Untermeyer Gardens. This is a neighborhood spot. Street parking was easy. Limited seating inside-we sat at the counter. We got the Lady Lover and El Dictador sandwiches. Both perfectly Toasty and filled with yummy ingredients. Definitely made w care and not “fast-food””."
"Arguably the best sandwiches in all of Yonkers, including the chopped cheese! The toastiest and most delicious hands down."