"I’m writing this review because Javi is the absolute best. He always takes care of me whenever I come into Buckeye Donuts! He has the biggest smile on his face and has an incredible attitude. It’s clear to see he is a real asset to Buckeye Donuts. Way to go Javi thank you for everything keep up the good work!"

"Visit 11-26-25 A tradition in Columbus for donuts. Our third time there and no disappointment. Buy three get one free. We love the glazed and lemon filled. Parking can be difficult through peak hours. Metered street parking. Staff was courteous and helpful."

"Grabbed a couple of donuts before the OSU game while walking around campus. A nostalgic place that has been on campus for as long as I can remember. There was a line to get in but they moved everyone through the line quickly. Grabbed a creme stick, and a pumpkin spice donut and both were very tasty."

"Yep, this place is good. Full selection of doubts, and other food mind you, but come for the donuts. Right off campus of OSU, so it’s a perfect location. Open 24/7 for all your snacking needs. They usually have a deal by x many and get one free, worth the extra to take home, or make new friends."

"Picked this shop as it was recommended as the best apple fritter in Columbus. So as an apple fritter lover I had high hopes. For me this is not a great apple fritter. I look for a nice crispy outside, soft chewy inside with the obvious chunks of apples. This one had the crispy outside but the inside felt a little dry and lacked any apple chucks. Had they had apple chunks inside It probably would have helped with multitude and been perfect. But as it was it felt like it was at least a half day old and not that great. The blueberry donut had a good flavor but again felt maybe older than desireable. I understand they are 24hrs but some things tasted to have certainly been on the shelf just as many hours. I know the blueberry donuts usually aren’t as airy as a plain glazed and more cake like but this one was dense and slightly dry. As for the service, that was 5 star. The cashier was helpful, and patient while I decided what I wanted and got request from others over the phone. I will say while I was already getting the Apple fritter he recommend that and the blueberry which both missed the mark. Maybe they are/were slow sellers and that was his way of pushing them but they were not what he claimed they would be. “Top favorites” Over all decent service but low grade donuts and unfortunate I can’t eat the service. Late night cravings this place would be perfect. For fresh quality donuts with good filling in the morning probably not the best choice."