"This was incredible! One of the top ice cream places I have been to. They were very friendly and gave lots of samples and suggestions. I loved their little metal tasting spoons! The Salted peanut with chocolate flecks was my favorite. I highly recommend it. The waffle cone piece was actually really good. I don't usually like those, but this one elevated the ice cream instead of distracting from it."

"I knew about Jeni’s ice cream’s quality and prices since we have some locations in the Chicagoland area. The people complaining about the prices should probably find a cheaper alternative. Like Ben and Jerry’s, there will always be customers so prices are not going to decrease. With that said, this location in the North Market is a great option for dessert. There are limited seats/tables right by the shop. If not you can find some upstairs. Customer service was great, employees were very helpful with samples and moving the line along. We sampled merry berry, boozy eggnog, and white chocolate peppermint. I like the white chocolate peppermint the most but the other two flavors are also good. You get more ice cream in a cup vs cone."

"Recommend: brambleberry crisp, honey vanilla bean, Good: sparkling cherry pie Ok: nebula berry, purple star born Meh: waffle cone I'm impressed by how tart nebula berry was but it wasn't to our taste. Ice cream is lovely and has a very clean finish but melts quickly. The employees are kind and offer samples I was not particularly a fan of the waffle cone which was pretty salty and in my opinion, it didn't need the salt."

"This is a busy place later in the day! After noting the traffic patterns on walks through the market, I decided to visit a little after their opening on a Saturday at 9am. I was able to easily look at the offerings and sit at one of the few tables right at the shop. I selected three flavors to try: double dough, salted caramel, and Texas sheet cake. I can see why Jeni’s gets so much hype, because not only were they delicious, but the texture was smooth and wonderful."

"Ice creams really overpriced. It's not a place that you can bring like your whole family. If you're on a budget, you'll spend for a family of four for just ice cream, almost $70. If you just want one scoop in a cone, the flavors are okay but she has had so many issues with bacteria. You're almost hesitant to even try it, but for me ice cream is supposed to be a fun thing for families and kids and older people grandparents on down, but the price is so expensive. I feel that some grandparents that are on a budget if they have a lot of grandkids. Can't afford to bring them and really have a good time like you will at your other places like dairy, Queen and other ice cream parlors"