"A must!! If you're a lover of Italian food, pizza, diner sandwiches, or in-house made soup, you will LOVE this little restaurant. It's an intergenerational, locally owned and ran restaurant. I had the lasagna, and I'll be dreaming of it often! It's just short, and I mean, just short of life changing. Everything is tasty, fresh, and a completely comfortable environment. A lot of different aged people, from young to elderly, and everyone was happily together. Just a treasure to the community. Def affordable, and generous portions, and Family Size offerings. Parking lot is limited, so ride together, if you can, just to be safe, but GO! You'll be so pleased!"

"Going here feels like stepping back to a bygone era! Big fan of all of the historic Columbus memorabilia. Ordered a turkey sandwich and meatball sub. Both were absolutely delicious and toasted to perfection. Very reasonable price point, and service was thoughtful and friendly."

"I visited here on Saturday, for the first time. I came in with a hankering for a toasted club sandwich. WoW! I am glad I ordered one, because it was amazing! The bacon was perfect salty and crispy. The ham and turkey was very generously stacked on the sandwich. The table next to me had a yummy-looking pizza. I didn't even know Smith's had pizza on the menu. Then I noticed the pizza oven. So, I ordered one to take home. It was also incredibly delicious! I'll definitely be back. The vibe was laid-back, and everyone seemed happy. The sounds of the customers chatting, the sounds of the fountain pop being poured, and the music olaying softly in the background, was like the soundtrack. The customer service was exceptional and genuine. Oh....and make sure to grab a cookie or three."

"Driven by hundreds of times but never stopped so today we fixed that. This is a serious old school delicious but it was a great experience. The staff was friendly and accommodating. The prices are great, and the food is really good. I had the Smiths sub with 2 sides and a cookie. The sub was good, the sides were homemade ( potatoe salad and pasta salad) and the cookies was delicious. Wifie had a salad which she really enjoyed. Some folks won't like the interior decor because it is dated but the food and service make that a mute point. I wished we had visited earlier because there is more depth to their menu to explore."

"Writing from my Grandson’s phone! Today was Grandparents day and we were looking for the perfect nostalgic spot after baseball practice. We sauntered in on a lovely Fall evening - we had the sense this place had been around for a while. There was a friendly atmosphere, and the place was bustling with locals. We said hello to the kind couple next to us who recommended the veggie lasagna. We walked up front to order, and decided on the lasagne and a BLT. The BLT was pretty standard, but the lasagna was truly special. The warmth and flavor of the cascade of tomato sauce was akin to a hundred hugs from our little Sonny bear! Highly recommend that dish Will be returning on a cold winter’s night for a cozy meal! 6.8/10"