"Visiting from California, we came in looking for a true slice of OK pecan pie, and got so much more. We came in the day before Thanksgiving to find they were sold out of slices and pies (reasonable once you taste them!). The owner, going way above and beyond was there and she gave us the pie from a cancelled order. The pie itself was incredible. The nutty custard was smooth and light. The pecan topping crumbled easily into a perfectly complimentary crunch. It travelled well and was a hit at our Thanksgiving celebration."

"Needed pie for a special occasion, but not a whole pie, so opted for slices of three varieties: maple pecan, black bottom banana cream, and peanut butter. While I would like a stronger peanut butter flavor, that slice was good. The maple pecan was extremely well-received, as well (we'll be buying a whole pie at some point). We have yet to try the banana, but it looks as though it's going to be a winner. Staff was very friendly and know their product well, which was nice when I asked for recommendations. I would go back strictly based on employee helpfuness and kindness. This is a place you do not want to miss!"

"The employees of this establishment are always fabulous! I was never a pie fan, but since visiting Railyard Pie, I have turned a new leaf! The owner, Lynn, and the head bakers, Brittany and Tayler, are some of the most genuine and honest people I've met. Watching them take care of their customers and their shop makes me feel like I'm in a movie -- not to mention watching them bake! I had an issue with an order I had placed, but rather than making me feel embarrassed or like an idiot, whoever answered the phone fixed it right away. Despite their business during the holidays, they were still accommodating and took good care of me! Stop by if you can, they make our small downtown strip feel like home!"

"It was National Coconut Cream Pie Day and so I had to come to my favorite place to get my slice of pie! IMO - they have the best Coconut Cream Pie! You can’t go wrong because there is so much goodness in this store! If you haven’t been this is a must visit!"

"The 2 ladies there were so, so nice and kind! And the suggestions they made were absolutely delicious. My 10 yo had some whoopie pies and loved them; I had a Mae's pie and it was deliiiiiicious (highly recommended). We would definitely will visit this place again, everything was very tasty, prices were good, the place is impecable, the music and atmosphere perfect to enjoy it with friends."