"A fun little place to stop for a dessert or a quick bite. Very friendly service, we enjoyed a Mississippi mud, and a slice of hummingbird cake. The cake was almost like a spice and banana cake mix. It's frosting was great. The Mississippi mud was a smaller treat, but also enjoyable. There was a variety of desserts to chose from. I didn't really look at the food menu, but I gather it was different style sandwiches, but look up their menu to be certain. A large sitting area, very enjoyable atmosphere and experience. Stop by and try!"

"Great lunch spot although it would be so nice to have a few gluten free options. I was surprised not to find any. Usually at small boutique type restaurants they have a few accommodations but I found very little I could eat safely. I ended up picking the croutons out of a delicious little spinach salad and taking some peanut butter cookies home. There recipe for those is GF, so that was great. Other than that my kids all enjoyed the sandwiches and salads they ordered and we, of course, couldn't leave without cookies. Whenever we come here it's necessary to spend the time and money to get the best sugar cookies on the planet. It's a family tradition! They are expensive but worth it. Even though I cannot indulge in them anymore my family loves them. Service was friendly if a little slow. Nobody is in an excessive hurry here but they get the job done. Overall very nice people and good quality food. We have enjoyed Katy's Pantry since moving to Enid and will continue to eat here and order cakes and pies. Just hoping to see more GF options someday."

"Only went for LUNCH, not for sweets, but it was my first time here. Fresh, tasty, affordable. My only two gripes were an overcooked, green-yolk hard boiled egg and water with a weird aftertaste. I could overlook it for every other part of the meal. Quiet place, decent options. Dressing was delish. Sweet potato fries too. And the homemade bread is worth the visit alone. UPDATE Nov 2025: got caramel pecan cheesecake! The chocolate on it was the best."

"A great selection of treats, clean atmosphere and helpful staff. We bought an entire chocolate cake for a birthday and a slice of cherry pie. They were so good!"

"Our experience was good. We had several items. Mexican casserole was good. The quiche had really flaky crust and tasted great. The vegetable soup and Wisconsin Cheese soup are tasty. The sugar cookies taste good with or without icing. Good portions and reasonable prices. Too full to try any other desserts. Our food came out in reasonable time. I think people need to remember this is not fast food restaurant. The person at the counter could have been a little friendlier to first time customers, but other than that was worth the stop."