"I had a few different flavors and enjoyed them all. The coconut gelato was better than I expected—it had a light texture with bits of coconut that added something interesting. The place is calm and clean. I’d come back to try more."

"Pure ecstasy. Both Gelato and Sorbet were amazing. Rival in taste to Gelato we had in Italy."

"Experiencing this level of gelato is a gift. Experiencing it in Stillwater, Oklahoma is a true surprise and delight moment. Blue Spruce has figured life out — at least in terms of making exceptional gelato and a welcoming, well put together space for people to gather. The most stressful part of my visit to Oklahoma was deciding which flavors to get. Naturally, I had to go two days in a row to fit it all in: Cookie butter, chocolate cake, coconut, and key lime pie. See my dilemma? All were superb. Somehow the cookie crumbs in the cookie butter were still crispy. How?! Magic. 🪄 I love ice cream. And I love great ice cream even more. Blue Spruce just raised that bar. Go here — and allow time to contemplate which flavors suit your mood that day."

"Nice surprise today while in from out - of - town trying to locate a specialty shop for icecream. The combos for 3 sorbets ( dairy- free) raspberry, chocolate chip gelato were amazing. Great tunes provided the atmosphere and a very clean place. Hubby had drip coffee black that was one of the smoothest cofeee he’s had. Bean roasting area in picture."

"Cute place with shopping all around! It was so good!"