"This place isn't new, but its new to me and I'm so excited to have found it!!! I ordered a slice of French Silk pie that I enjoyed there and I am taking a slice of Key Lime home for my hubby! The French Silk pie was so silky smooth, wonderful chocolate flavor, not overly sweet and the crust was buttery crispy flaky and the whole thing was made with love, the most amazing slice of French Silk pie!! I can't wait to come back and see what seasonal goodies they have!"

"We loved this experience from start to finish! The pie was delicious. The atmosphere was relaxing. The games were fun. Try the apple crumb!"

"Super cute cafe....we went in around 2pm on a Wednesday....there was 1 person waiting on a large order and 1 person checking out....we were greeted promptly and was told they would be right with us....they had 8ish slices of different flavored pies on display....they had a board of 'featured pies'. We got 3 slices of pie; coconut cream, chocolate chip cookie pie and a featured blueberry pie.....all were out of this world delish....we spent 24$ all together, 8$ a piece, which is reasonable, and I'd be happy to pay that for local home grown entrepreneurs....way to go!!! Keep up the good work....oh, and you can buy whole pies 🥧 😋"

"Common Tart is such a midtown gem! It’s tucked away on E 17th Street next to Utica Park Urgent Care and across from the Chapman Child Learning Center. The atmosphere is chic yet cozy, with a piano, table games, and comfortable seating. It is a smaller space, but perfect for enjoying a slice of pie. This was my first time trying a savory option—the green chili chicken enchilada pie—and it was absolutely delicious. I’ve also had a few of their sweet pies, and they’re heavenly. Today I tried the chocolate chip cookie pie, and both my heart and tummy were happy. Most importantly, the service was warm and welcoming. You can tell the owners take pride not only in their baking craft but also in building genuine connections with their customers."

"I was pleasantly surprised. We got four slices of pie: brownie , peppermint bark, peanut butter and apple. Those are the exact names of some of them but it's close enough. The place is small. Service was quick. We got there about 10 min before opening and the line was already in the street. They pies were good."