"Ye Old Sweet Shoppe did the cupcakes for our wedding. They were fabulous!!! We had a variety of different flavors that guests loved. Cookies and Cream, peanut butter, the list goes on! Not only did they taste amazing but they were beautiful. They also did gluten free cupcakes. Our guests were SO happy!!! Highly recommend!"

"I was looking for a very specific, very specially made style birthday cake for my wife. Had specifics on filling, style, toppings, everything. The team was very patient and attentive to every detail in taking my order, asked for reference photos, reaffirmed everything during the process, and hit an absolute home run in creation and execution. The cake was beautifully made, exactly to specifications, and just delicious. Appreciative of the team at Ye Ole for treating this order like it was for their own family!"

"I called from Washington state last week to see if I could order a birthday cake delivered to an address in Erie. I spoke with Renee. I just want to extend my highest compliments to Renee, to your bakery, and your delivery driver! The ordering was quick and super easy, the cake was PERFECT (and absolutely delicious!!!) the delivery was flawless (I added special door instructions which he followed to a tee!) the delivery driver was great and friendly, customer service absolutely top notch!!! Your bakery made my friend’s birthday amazing!! THANK YOU!!!"

"A wonderful hometown sweet treat bakery serving a wide variety of homemade cookies, cupcakes, brownies, cake pops, and cakes. Many cookies and cupcakes to choose from to satisfy everyone's sweet tooth! Try these cookies: Rocky Road, Butterball Cookies, Oatmeal Walnut, Chocolate Chip Walnut, Vanilla, for starters. An excellent taste like no other."

"I ordered my wedding cake and cupcakes from Ye Ole Sweet Shoppe and have nothing but great things to say. Delicious wedding cake for a really great price! They offer a sample box of 4 cake flavors and your choice of frostings and fillings to try with them. My husband and I enjoyed them all and struggled with our flavor selection. We settled on chocolate cake with chocolate frosting and fudge filling; almond cake with raspberry filling and raspberry whipped frosting. SO. GOOD. We had zero cupcakes left at our wedding with one guest informed us they had 4 cupcakes 😅 They were so easy to work with and have delicious cake! Can’t recommend them enough."