"From the moment we walked in, the vibe was buzzing—hip, modern, and full of energy. My wife ordered the bagel sandwich, and each bite delivered a burst of freshness, especially thanks to the vibrant, delicious pesto. I went with the Pastrami and Swiss, which was packed with bold, savory flavor, though the bread slightly outbalanced the fillings—I’d love a bit more pastrami next time! The fries were outstanding: perfectly crisp and golden, clearly made with care. To round out the meal, the organic tea amazed me with its subtle yet perfectly balanced flavors. Altogether, it’s easy to see why this spot draws a crowd. We left already planning our next visit."

"As someone with celiac disease, I was so impressed. The staff went over all the gluten-free options, explained their separate prep area and toaster, and made sure my allergy was noted. The food was delicious, the coffee was great, and the vibe is super fun and cozy."

"We live in the city and Amanita has quickly turned into one of our favorites breakfast spots in Lancaster. The food is fresh. Prices are fair. And the atmosphere is relaxing and kid friendly! Definitely recommend."

"Great service here. The staff are friendly and knowledgeable. Coffee: serves Passenger Coffee (not a fan, notes are tin and sour from Ethiopian beans) Breads: serves Elsewhere breads. Not too sweet like others, but supposed to be sourdough (didn't get the taste) Cookies: serves Front Porch cookies and biscotti. Biscotti were good. I would like to try their lunch menu but we came too early."

"⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Amanita is such a gem in Lancaster! The atmosphere is warm and welcoming, with a unique charm that makes you want to linger. The staff are incredibly friendly and knowledgeable, and you can tell they truly care about the quality of what they offer. Everything is beautifully presented, fresh, and full of flavor — a real treat for the senses. Whether you’re stopping in for a quick bite or planning a relaxed visit with friends, this place is a must-try. Highly recommend!"