"I’m one of those people who only ever reads reviews. So this one’s for all of you like me—the judgmental mutes who can’t be bothered to leave feedback because of the usual letdown when reality doesn’t match the hype. I think we can all agree that since COVID-19, food quality in restaurants has declined proportionally to the general unhappiness we see in the world. I’ve been debating whether good food just doesn’t exist anymore or if the virus genuinely rewired my taste buds. One of those staples I think we all search for is the classic American breakfast in a small mom-and-pop setting. This is it, folks. Let’s start with the best bacon I’ve ever had—thick-cut, better than Smithfield. When Johnny, the owner, approached our table with the most chill lumberjack energy imaginable, we had to ask about it. Turns out he sources it from Groff’s up in Elizabethtown, and it’s so damn good I’m making a trip there myself. This guy owns the restaurant—a first-year owner with the literal words out of his mouth being, “I want to keep this small and homey.” You can feel that intention in every detail. The pancakes? Absolutely smash. Fresh squeezed orange juice? Tastes like they’re straight from Florida, picked this morning. If you’ve been chasing that nostalgic, no-frills breakfast experience and coming up empty, stop searching. You found it."

"During my daughter’s volleyball tournament we visited this little breakfast spot, and it was such a delightful experience! The atmosphere was warm and inviting, perfect for a relaxed morning meal. What really made the visit special was how accommodating the staff were—they went above and beyond to make my daughter feel special by preparing custom waffles just for her! She absolutely loved them, and it turned our breakfast into a memorable family moment. The food was fresh, flavorful, and clearly made with care. If you’re looking for a charming place with great food and exceptional service, this is it. Highly recommended!"

"Unbelievable service and hospitality...eclectic, charming atmosphere...fantastically flavorful fresh food...need I say more?! I recommend the Swedish pancakes and fresh squeezed OJ!"

"I ABSOLUTELY LOVE THIS PLACE! Not only was the food so tasty ( I ordered the Florentine omelette) but the owner Johnny was so incredibly genuine, warm and welcoming. If I ever find myself in downtown Lancaster again, I am definitely coming back!! Thank you again “On Orange” for a wonderful breakfast!❤️❤️"

"I've lived in lancaster almost my whole life and never knew this place existed. It is absolutely freaking adorable. It's a while vibe. The owner was super chill and the wait staff was great. The food was so good. I'm definitely coming here again and spreading the word. Thank you so much for this first time experience. 💕"