"One of our favorite bar/restaurants in Old City. Consistently excellent service at the bar or a table. Friendly staff. Live music Sundays , Tuesdays, and special events. The food is SO good. Handicapped accessible (there’s a 2nd floor, but bar, restrooms and main dining area are accessible. Fireplace in the winter. Outdoor tables on the sidewalk for nice weather. Everything is wonderful here!"

"Mouth watering food and welcoming atmosphere. The clamp soup was one of the best so far. Staff interactions with costumers was friendly and polite all the time."

"The day after the wedding, we were completely snowed in and ended up at the Plough & the Stars for breakfast… and stayed for the entire day! The hospitality from the staff was incredible. They graciously accommodated our group of over 70 people without missing a beat. Izzy was absolutely amazing—serving us all day with patience, kindness, and a constant smile. The food was fantastic, the music was great, and the football games kept everyone entertained. THANK YOU to everyone who made our unexpected snow day so memorable—especially Izzy! It was truly exceptional."

"Awesome place to eat and hang out. The food was great, the drinks were great, the atmosphere is perfect, and the company couldn't have been better. 3 of us had dinner here and time flew by. The fireplace kept us warm, the waitress was always checking in on us and it was such a great time. The fireplace was perfect with for cold weather too. I had an old fashioned and buffalo chicken tenders. If I came back to eat here I would do that exact combo again and maybe add the fries too because they looked incredible."

"We had dinner at the Plough. It was fantastic. We were met by our witty host with a heavy Irish accent who seated us. Eva was our wait person. She was attentive, friendly, and always available. We had the Ribeye Pork and the Guinness Casserole. They were outstanding meals. Cooked to perfection. The atmosphere was local and genuine. Prices were reasonable. Go and enjoy the Plough."