"Surprisingly the first time I was ever here .. great little dive bar! Great prices, and I was told they have very good food. A guy came in ordering a Reuben, said it is the heat around. I'll have to go back and try that out... Parking can be difficult, but I would definitely recommend stopping by here! Follow for more... Update; I have eaten here several times now, and everything is exceptional. Jerk grilled chicken sandwich was great, as are the Mac and cheese and Reuben. My daughter ordered seitan French dip, and I would highly recommend it. Definitely check this place out."

"I bought metal cabinets on Facebook Marketplace and they came with Steelers fridge magnets with Kellys on them from 1991. I looked the place up and saw it was still in business. My partner is vegetarian and I was happy at all of the vegetarian options. We decided to pay Kellys a visit over the weekend and were very happy with the experience and the service. I had the biggest fish sandwich I have ever seen and my partner enjoyed the vegan wings. We appreciated that Kellys played really good music also. I'm so glad we found this place. We will be back ."

"We visited in September 2024 and raved about this place, from the food to the service to the vibe. We were so excited to stop on this time, only to be majorly let down. Like other reviews have stated, the service was lackluster. Much of our food was overcooked and burned. The male server was curt and said it’s how it’s suppose to be, but that’s not how it’s been in the last. We brought friends to show this place off and our whole table left disappointed. Unfortunately we will likely not recommend this place in the future."

"Insanely expensive for a dive bar. Most drafts are $9 and above. Bartender was pretty rude and inattentive. We brought about 10 of the 14 people to the bar, but she wanted to talk to regulars and treat us like crap."

"Kelly’s is exactly what I want in a neighborhood bar. It’s small. It’s dark. There is one side which hosts a massive rail and other intimate booths which run parallel. The music was on point all evening. We came after a Pirates game and it was slammed, after waiting for five minutes we got a table. The food here is homey. Massive portions and definitely proper pub food. Went with the fish sandwich, Cajun meatloaf and Mac and cheese. The fish sandwich is massive. It needs sauce, so make sure to coat the boat in provided tarter. The meatloaf had a nice kick and was smothered in perfectly cooked onions. The Mac and cheese was good, albeit not the most amazing and didn’t live up to the hype for me. I would, however, order it again. If you’re looking for a cool spot in a gentrified neighborhood, Kelly’s is your go-to."