"What a fantastic find! I was so excited to try Geoff's Superlative Sandwiches after hearing all the great things, and it absolutely lived up to the hype. The menu is massive, and I love that I could go back over and over and try something new every time. I went with the Providence Monthly from the "Favs" menu, and it was a 10/10. The bread was perfect, and the toppings were incredibly fresh and well-balanced. The fries were a great choice too. Even though it was packed, the staff was awesome and handled the rush like pros. I'm already looking forward to my next visit!"

"Ordered the sandwich online, Friday around 11. The two sandwiches were just finishing. They were delicious! The bread roll was soft and flavors great. This shop had many choices to choose from and online ordering was easy to customize! The staff lady prepping the sandwich wasn’t mean but she definitely wasn’t friendly either. No “welcome” or “have a nice day”. It was “I made the sliced bread sandwich with wheat bread, is that ok?”- “well too late now so I guess so” - I didn’t say that, I said it was fine. I’m not gonna wait for a new sandwich. No napkins in the bag. The floor inside was super sticky under my shoes which is an indication the rest of the restaurant/kitchen is not too clean. They use the wrong cleaning detergent or not washing the floor enough. I would probably go back to try another sandwich."

"Great sandwiches and soups! Our group of ten (six adults and four kids) stopped in for lunch on a Saturday. Just beat the rush. Very friendly and efficient staff. Huge selection of sandwiches with names from Providence culture, politics, media, sports, etc."

"Our family visit here for lunch, we had high expectations which fell short. My Providence Monthly barely had any chicken on it, my daughter’s David Cicilline had way too big of a bun/bread for the proportion of meat, they were out of certain breads, and the side pickles tasted sour."

"I did a 25 sandwich order for work on DoorDash, but when I went to check out it had an error about "options not nesting correctly." A quick Google search indicated it was an error of how the merchant set up its menu. So, two stars off. However, I was able to get the group lunch by calling the shop and doing a catering order. What was supposed to be a social lunch in the office turned into a grab and go experience because the food was an hour late. The sandwiches were delicious and the fries were crispy. I got the Dead Head with Havarti cheese and bacon on a spinach wrap. Fresh and tasty."