About My Favorite Muffin
My Favorite Muffin is a beloved Warwick gathering spot where community and craft truly come together. With a passionate team that remembers regulars by name and freshly baked goods that keep customers coming back, this independent cafe offers the warmth and authenticity you won't find at chain coffee shops. Whether you're grabbing a perfectly made coffee, a creative sandwich, or one of their signature baked treats, you'll experience the genuine care that's earned them a devoted following and stellar 4.5-star reputation.
What People Are Saying
from Google & Yelp"I ordered a bacon, egg, and cheese on their cinnamon French toast bagel and WOW, absolutely delicious! 10/10 would recommend. Especially because everyone who works here is so welcoming and lovely. A must go! (Photo is only of half my sandwich because I inhaled the first half)"
"Love this place! The staff are always friendly and upbeat. The manager knows her customers and takes great care of them. She checked with her employees a couple of times before checkout to make sure the order was just right. The food was amazing like always. Also, the reusable tin is super convenient. Thanks again!"
"Genuinely a hidden gem. I saw it while driving home from a morning job and I’m so glad I stopped. I went in for just one muffin and ended up walking out with a 6-pack and a bagel 😂 Since I’d never been before, I had to give some of the flavors a try. I was really hoping for a lemon poppyseed, but their only lemon option was a Lemon Blueberry Cheesecake. It’s actually really good, just not my thing since I’m not the biggest cheesecake fan—so it was kinda sad not to see another lemon one. I ended up getting that, plus Chocolate Peanut Butter Explosion, Apple Pie Deep Dish, Cinnamon Crumb Cake, and Georgia Peach. There were soooo many options, even for bagels! I tried a little of each and they were so tasty. I just know they’re gonna smack even more once I toast them at home. I ended up grabbing a Cinnamon Toast Bagel too, which was also amazing—just a little on the doughy side. I wish I had asked for it extra-toasted, but I didn’t think to at the time. Definitely will next time! Still, it was really good, and I love that they offer a bunch of different cream cheese flavors to choose from. You seriously gotta stop by and try this place!"
"Local business, service and food are both excellent. They have a nice variety of muffins and bagels. I know it's named with the muffin but both muffins AND bagels are of the highest quality. They also have mini muffins which are great for trying out new flavors. I have had both muffins and bagel and would be hard pressed to say which were better. Get both."
"Stopped in after dropping my daughter at the airport. Ordered a bagel with cream cheese and a coffee. The staff are all friendly and quick with service. The bagel was SO SO YUMMY! Normally I eat a half then the other half for lunch but this was so yummy I are the whole bagel and wished I bought a dozen to take home."
"10/10! Stopped in on my way back to Pennsylvania, just typed in coffee and this place popped up. I feel so lucky we found this gem, my cappuccino was..."
