"First time going and definitely will be back for our last day in state tomorrow. The staff and owner is beyond kind and quick to get your orders done. I got an iced latte with a mocha shot and a veggie cream cheese everything bagel…needless to say it was the best coffee I’ve had in the area and their bagels are NY styled. The seating areas are comfy, cozy, and clean. If you haven’t stopped in yet I highly urge you to do so. Spread love to your locals ❤️"

"Jamey’s custom-made cakes, tarts and other bakery items are stellar. For my daughter’s 21st, she made this cake. I told her my daughter liked “vintage” and she interpreted it so creatively — and spot on! Not only was the cake unique and beautiful — it was absolutely delicious. I also order a gorgeous lemon tart every Easter, which the entire extended family looks forward to. Highly recommend for special occasion bakery items. PS her blueberry muffins are the best I’ve had."

"We couldn’t be happier with our custom lemon cake from Fresh Cup Café in Westerly, Rhode Island! The fondant design was absolutely perfect, and every detail we requested was captured beautifully. It looked incredible and tasted just as amazing. My daughter loved it. The cake truly made her birthday extra special. Thank you for your care, creativity, and craftsmanship. We can’t imagine going anywhere else for our special cake needs! ❤️"

"Fresh Cup hosted my daughter’s baby shower this weekend. The food, atmosphere, and customer service was beyond compare. Jamey and her staff were amazing. All the guests felt comfortable and welcome. The food was delicious and there was so much of it! Fresh Cup also has the best coffee around. I highly recommend having Fresh Cup cater your special event. You will not be disappointed."

"Fresh Cup Cafe isn't just a place to grab a bite; it’s a genuine slice of warm, welcoming hospitality right here in Westerly, RI. If you're looking for fantastic food served with care, this is the place to be. We recently stopped in for lunch and were absolutely delighted by everything we tried. The Turkey Mozzarella Melt was perfectly savory and gooey—a deeply satisfying sandwich that is now my daughter's new favorite thing. My personal highlight was the Chicken Salad Sandwich, which I ordered on their gluten-free bread. It’s genuinely some of the best gluten-free bread I’ve ever tasted, proof that they take quality seriously across the board when gluten free can be hit or miss. We also enjoyed a classic Everything Bagel with cream cheese, which was fresh and perfectly toasted. What truly sets this cafe apart is the heart behind it. The owner's incredible commitment to the community and her customers shines through in every interaction. That dedication translates directly into the amazing atmosphere and exceptional service. It’s these thoughtful touches that turn a simple lunch outing into a truly special experience. We highly recommend Fresh Cup Cafe for any meal, whether you’re local or just passing through. Stop in, enjoy the delicious food, and say hello to the best owner in town! Go there! Tell your friends!"