"We went here for Saturday brunch and there wasn’t a wait at all! Super cute atmosphere and fun menu choices, and the french toast was phenomenal. Only negative for us - the sausage patty on the breakfast sandwich was essentially an enormous Italian meatball in a not-super-positive way. Dinner menu looks lovely too and we’ll be excited to try it one day soon!"

"Great setting and ambience for a place that can accommodate large groups. Good selection of specialty cocktails. "Spicy" options are Utah spicy. Thought the pasta was slightly overcooked. Great desserts in a cup! Both cheesecake and tira misu. Would definitely repeat."

"We recently dined at this incredible Italian restaurant in Salt Lake City, and it was a true delight from start to finish. The flavors were rich, vibrant, and unmistakably authentic—every bite transported us straight to Italy. From the perfectly al dente spaghetti to the savory sauces and fresh ingredients, it’s clear the kitchen takes pride in traditional recipes and quality preparation. The ambiance was cozy and welcoming, ideal for a relaxed evening out. The staff were friendly and attentive, adding to the overall warmth of the experience. We especially appreciated the thoughtful touches and genuine hospitality. If you're craving real Italian cuisine that’s both delicious and soul-satisfying, this spot is a must-visit. We loved it and can’t wait to return!"

"Bartolo’s is a great spot with a very comfortable, easygoing atmosphere that makes conversation effortless. It’s the kind of place where you can relax and actually enjoy the experience without feeling rushed or crowded. Our server was friendly, professional, and genuinely helpful, offering excellent recommendations that paid off. The crab frittata was outstanding—rich, flavorful, and perfectly cooked—and even the coffee stood out as excellent, which is always appreciated. Between the welcoming service, relaxed atmosphere, and quality food, Bartolo’s is a place I would happily return to and recommend to others."

"Great Experience. Our server Dixter is the best he gave us good recommendations and he’s tight! Food is really great. The porkchop marsala is my favorite and their blueberry pancakes is the best in town its a must try. Highly recommended"