"Ordered the West Coaster and it was honestly one of the worst sandwich I’ve ever had. It’s supposed to have turkey, sun-dried tomatoes, and slices of avocado, but what I got was super disappointing. The bread was weirdly soft, the lettuce was wilted, and there was just a tiny smear of avocado mash instead of real slices. I counted maybe three sun-dried tomatoes, all rock-hard. No mayo, no flavor — just a dry, bland sandwich that made me laugh when I saw it. Not worth $15 at all. Do better."

"Decent flavor and location; however, I may avoid ordering another $13 “chicken pesto panini on sourdough” - the bread size/style is ever-changing — first time ordering it was made with artisan-style sourdough, not this time! Service was quick since it was ordered online."

"After just eating an amazing Burrito at The Mad Taco - I wanted to have something sweet. I stumble across Otter Creek Bakery. The young lady at the counter was pleasant and service was excellent. This is a quaint little bakery - I am very one-track minded when entering a bakery - All trains must lead to chocolate! My blood type is Hershey's Positive. So, I didn't even look elsewhere in the display cases which had many other lovely items. - let others be the judge of those. I asked for her for her most chocolate experience. It was either a cookie or one of the muffins. I got the Smores and the Other one (I forgot which it was). Order total was $11 for 2 muffins. They were okay - But, honestly not memorable. The muffin base was heavy and a bit dry. The smores muffin had a nice graham cracker bottom and a marshmellow top - which made the muffin fun and enjoyable to eat. It had a mixture of flavor which gave this dessert experience a nice treat. The other muffin I forgot what is was - So, like I said, it was okay - just not memorable. I enjoyed sitting in the patio area under a nice shade. The muffins satisfied my need to get some chocolate into my bloodstream. However, this was not an "over-the-top" chocolate experience."

"Would give 3.5 Stars. Cute little sandwich shop and bakery with a lot of menu options, including vegetarian options. Sandwiches had nice flavor, but bread wasn’t great. The Rainbow Veggie Sandwich was more unique. We also got the Lemon Pecan cookie, which was pretty tasty. I would go back again for lunch or a sweet treat."

"This was my third visit and definitely my last. Each visit has not been enjoyable and has been over priced. All three experiences have been that things look good but taste mediocre. The first two visits were for take out bakery items. This last visit my sandwich cost $17.00. The price was not listed. It took a very long time for them to make it. It was okay but nothing spectacular and not better than a sandwich from home. It was definitely not worth the wait or the money! There are no paper plates to eat on. The tables are dirty and visually unappealing. I do not recommend this place."