"Truly the best cheesecake in the state. Over the past 20 years, I have tried cheesecakes from all over the state, and country, and this truly is the best I have had. The baker must have a special touch that no one else does. Everything I have tried from this store is exceptional, from the cookies, to the cake pops or even the Kringle, however the cheesecake still gets my vote every time. I cannot say enough about this little amazing bakery! If you don’t visit when you’re in Green Bay, you are missing out!"

"10/10 recommend! This was my first time in the bakery and I’m very impressed. The turtle cheesecake tacos were a huge hit with my friends. They were delicious and I can’t wait to try more. The gentleman who helped me even gave me a sample of their new grasshopper cheesecake and little did he know how much I love mint chocolate. I will definitely be back!"

"My whole experience with FiveThumbsUp has been wonderful from start to finish. I gave the lady just a general idea of what I wanted and told her I trusted her judgement on this one. I wanted this because my boyfriend loves halloween and cheesecake. What better combo to have for a birthday cake? She set up a pick up date for a day she wasnt even open as well! (The birthday happened to fall on a day she wasnt open) Truly above and beyond service! Thank you so much and I will be ordering again in the future!"

"These cheesecakes are the best I’ve ever had! My husband swore he didn’t like cheesecake but after trying an Oreo cheesecake cupcake he was hooked! I love the samplers with delicious, fun flavors!"

"Best cheesecake I've ever had! Haven't been to the downtown Green Bay location yet, but can't wait to try it out! I love the sampler cheesecakes to try different flavors."