"I almost don’t have words for how good their sandwiches are. I’ve eaten from here several times, and every time it’s just as amazing! You cannot go wrong with any of their sandwiches, but my personal favorite is the Italian. Meatball sandwich on Mondays is very good too. Staff are always super friendly. Oh and those cookies, get 2 or 3 because one isn’t enough!! Their sandwiches are SO GOOD, seriously I think about the Italian often and will never forget the first time I ate one. Outstanding!!"

"Best. Sandwiches. Ever. I am a creature of habit and have gotten their Italian sandwich on focaccia every time. Recently I tried the Dutch crunch roll and OMG that changed the game. Lettuce and tomatoes drenched in dressing, just the right amount of layers of meat and cheese, and freshly baked bread make Casetta superior and utterly crave-able.🥪🌞 The staff is so friendly and efficient; they manage their high volume of orders/customers like pros. Love this place!"

"Checked this place out because of the hype… but left somewhat disappointed. The restaurant itself is beautiful and smells of fresh bread. There was a long line out the door so I had high hopes. I ordered the daily special… “The Mac”: a chicken cutlet sandwich on lettuce, onion, and provolone with special sauce. Sounds delicious. They made my sandwich quick and I was out the door. 6 minutes later, back home and time to eat. But to my surprise, the ciabatta buns were already soggy and the chicken cutlets were hard crisps. Not sure if it’s because I went about an hour and a half before close, but seemed like the cutlets were fried in the morning and reused. The overall flavor was pretty good, and hey for $12 you can’t really expect anything anymore these days… but I guess I don’t understand the hype of this place. Perhaps I went on the wrong day, wrong time, or got the wrong sandwich, as there wouldn’t be a line out the door if this place truly was just average. Perhaps I’ll give it another shot another day because I certainly do want to like this place. But for now… Casetta is nothing more than an aesthetic sandwich shop for people that think they’re too hipster for jimmy johns."

"Dutch crunch bread & GF focaccia, two solid delicious bread options. Fresh ingredients, nice staff & drink options are superb. The Italian for the win!!"

"Ordered the Italian with the focaccia bread. For $12.50 let me tell you this sand-which is one of the best in town. You get a lot of your buck. I couldn’t finish it but will certainly be back."