"Michelangelo’s is great any time of day, any day of the week! A summer Saturday morning for an iced coffee during the farmers market, or a cold winter evening for specialty latte and a good book; it’s comfortable, cozy, welcoming, and delicious. There is always a fun drink to try."

"Great little coffee spot! Delicious coffee, friendly service, and honest staff. I even lost my card in the lobby, and when I went back and they had saved it for me. Truly appreciate that kind of care!"

"Stopped for a sweet tooth craving, tried their fruit smoothie, a pie and brownie. All good Staff is friendly"

"Michalangelo's is one of my favorite coffee shops because of the decor and their black forest cherry frappuccino. Im usually more of a cortado guy though and that isn't too bad. The chai and matcha are weak though and there are definitely places to get better espresso. Don't quote me on this but I think they have both a medium and a dark espresso roast. They are often very busy and sometimes it shows, last time I went the person at the register forgot to put my order in for the other baristas and I ended up waiting a while before realizing that no one would be making my coffee if I didn't say anything. No problem though, i mentioned this and they immediately put my cup in queue. Anyway, Michaelangelo's is the coffee chop closest to my heart but i'm giving it a 4/5 stars"

"i dont even live in Wisconsin, i went for a trip and we found this shop and let me tell you, THOSE HAM AND CHEDDAR BAGELS ARE THE BEST THINGS IVE EVER TRIED omg ive craved it ever since i left. i dont know what ham they use or what but i have never had a bagel so amazing in my life. i genuinely dream about this bagel i would travel the 8 hours every single week just for that bagel. i wake up in a cold sweat thinking about it, no one understands truly how in love i am with that bagel sandwich. thank you"