"At Random is a unique and fun experience! I love the ambiance- the deco, booths, bar area, and lighting take me to another time. It's beautiful inside and I love the red lighting. It's quite spacious with seating at the bar and booths in the front and back room. At Random also offers outdoor seating, weather permitting. I went on a Friday night around 7PM with three friends and we found seating in the back room right away at a spacious booth. The place filled up quick after we arrived, so we felt lucky! We all enjoyed our drinks and our waitress was very friendly. We ordered Hot Toddys and Irish Coffees to and our evening. Looking forward to going back!"

"I went to At Random for my 21st birthday which was so fun! My crew each had a different ice cream drink and they were soooo delicious. My honest review is that honestly the flavor could have been a little stronger for some of them but other than that they were sweet and tasty. I didn’t try any of their normal cocktails so I can’t speak to that. The atmosphere definitely was lounge vibes it’s dark and although they provide little lights know that it’s dark and moody and a little noisy. But it’s the whole point so that’s great! The wait staff were super friendly and did not “bother” us too often helped to enhance the overall vibe. The place was well decorated and had a nice outside area that was for self serve window style. Overall would love to go again!!!"

"My favorite bar in the world, seriously. Live in Chicago and come to Milwaukee frequently (where my bf is from) We hit At Random every single time we are in town. The vibe is amazing. Feels like you were transported back in time. We’ve tried about 10 different milkshakes, and each one is so dang good. My favorite is definitely the Grasshopper and the Strawberry Blondie, but every single one has been great. We’ve also tried a few different cocktails and they were also great. The ice cream they use is truly the best ice cream I’ve ever had in my life. (I believe it’s Cedar Crest?) Great vibes, Great service, Great Drinks, Great Prices for what you get!"

"We made a reservation. I recommend doing that. If there is no seating at the bar, you will not be allowed to stand and order. If you miss your reservation within 15 minutes, they will no longer accommodate it. There were eight of us. It was a Sunday night. We each ordered an ice cream drink. The snicker bar, the pink squirrel, the grasshopper, the chocolate raspberry. They have a happy hour that ended at 7 o’clock. $8 ice cream drinks, regularly $13. Drinks were delicious. But I was disappointed that half my drink was whipped cream. We were there for the experience and THAT did not disappoint. This is a classic Milwaukee cocktail lounge. A must when visiting."

"The atmosphere is great, the red lighting provides a romantic and cozy vibe and the ice cream drinks are delicious. Really appreciate that they can be made vegan as well!! The service is a little slow but understandable as it was busy. Overall a great date night location, can't wait to come back and sit outside."