"Such a great addition to the neighborhood! I’ve been to Poppy bakery three times and am impressed every single time. There is always a line, but it moves fast and is 100% worth the wait. The staff is always super friendly and the bake goods are top notch. The focaccia bread is my absolute favorite and if I didn’t think I was gonna be 500 pounds I would get it every weekend. The inside is cute with some seating. I love being able to see the baking area and items being made while I’m there. PSA: In a time when so many businesses are closing in MKE please support your local business ❤️"

"Easily takes the spot as the best bakery I’ve been to in & around Milwaukee. Got multiple items to try out and everything was delicious and moist. I don’t even like olives but still loved the focaccia bread I got for someone else. Will definitely be back to try other items"

"We have come here almost every single weekend since they have opened because it is that good! The baked goods are always incredibly fresh and delicious. I particularly like that they have some rotating seasonal flavors so that there's always something new to try. My personal favorite is their cinnamon roll, they somehow managed to make a cinnamon roll where everybody is like eating the very center of the roll. This is an absolute must try if you're in the Milwaukee area!"

"First time trying Poppy Bakery and we will definitely be back! When we arrived, line was out the door but for good reason, as the pastries we tried were out of this world! Line moved quickly and we were in and out in no time, but either way, definitely worth the wait. We tried the cinnamon roll, coffee cake, apple ginger scone and brown butter miso cookie, all of which were delicious! Definitely already planning our return visit 🍪"

"Great little neighborhood bakery and coffee shop. Pastries and breads to die for! We loved the focaccia and the cinnamon rolls, as well as the giant scones and lemon brioche."