"Tell Me If You Agree: Pick ’n Save – South Green Bay Rd, Mount Pleasant is the Grocery Store Version of a Theme Park 🎢 If you’ve ever wandered into the Pick ’n Save at 2820 S Green Bay Rd in Mount Pleasant, Wisconsin, you know it’s more than just a grocery run—it’s an experience. Open early (6 a.m.) and late (11 p.m.), this store is ready whether you’re fetching eggs for breakfast or ice cream at 10:45pm. What Hits Right 😄 Walking in, you are greeted by an aisle of possibilities. Fresh produce? Check. Cheese counters that whisper “Buy me”? Yep. Snacks that weren’t on your list but somehow hop into your cart? Absolutely. Their online pickup option adds a sprinkle of convenience — because sometimes you just want your groceries handed over without the 500-item “quick stop” loop. The team on the floor tends to be helpful, making even the most errand-heavy trip feel managed. What’s the Laughable Bit 🤔 If you go for one thing, budget for three. Pasta becomes “and we’ll grab dessert while we’re here” territory. There’s always that one shelf stocked with seasonal items you didn’t know you needed (hello, pumpkin-spiced something in June). And yes—self-checkout sometimes becomes a mini-game of “Does the barcode scan this time?” If you win, you leave with pride and maybe a candy bar. Side note: some reviews mentioned the price‐to‐experience ratio can feel a bit “ambient theme park ticket” instead of “discount grocery.” Final Verdict 💬 Pick ’n Save on South Green Bay Rd isn’t perfect, but it’s reliably spirited. For grocery shopping that feels more like a casual adventure than a chore—it delivers. Just remember: you’ll probably leave with more than you came for. And that’s kind of the point. Call to Action: Have you made a haul here recently? Drop a comment below telling us your best surprise find (or funniest checkout moment). Did you go in for eggs and come out with three bags of snacks? We want to hear it! 👇"

"I always preferred this location of pic n save over all others, every one is so courteous and eager to help. But I am currently on the phone with the customer service line because my card was fraudulently charged for $22.30 and its just wild that in these times where every penny counts that this would happen , I deleted all of my cards off the file /website and I wont feel comfortable shopping there anymore. I just was so grateful for my after hours pick up order being given to me last night and now this. It’s unfortunate. God bless. Back to walmart and woodmans I go."

"They have a great selection and always something I need on sale, only downside is they never enough cashiers to check out and the self check out is always packed."

"Updated Review - 3/12/23: I added a few pics of the outside of the store. ----------------------------------------------- I already know that the grocery store should be the last place you should be buying sushi…. But there is another grocery store in town that has sushi as good as any Sushi Restaurant around here. So, I thought I would give it a try. It was not good. The fish was fresh, but the rice was as hard as a rock. I ate two whole pieces with fish and rice and had to stop. It ended up I just ate the fish off the top and threw the rice away. I had the Nigiri/Maki Combo…. Salmon, Tuna, Shrimp, Octopus, and Yellow Tail… with Wasabi, Ginger, and Soy Sauce. I would think twice about buying sushi at Pick n Save again…. So… 3 stars for the sushi. (because the fish was fresh.) The good news is the grocery store is 5 stars! Average of the two ratings is…. 4 stars!!!"

"I love this location! My only issue is some of the produce was not priced and one of the cashier's that seemed like he was supposed to be paying attention to the self checkouts seemed more concerned with his phone."