About Johnston's Bakery
Step into Johnston's Bakery, a beloved local institution where tradition meets warmth in the heart of Sheboygan. This family-owned gem has earned its stellar 4.7-star reputation by doing what chains simply can't—crafting genuine connections with neighbors and visitors alike. Whether you're a local seeking your favorite corner or a traveler discovering a hidden treasure, you'll find the authentic charm and personal touch that makes independent bakeries the soul of their communities.
What People Are Saying
from Google"This bakery was suggested by a local and I saw it on tik tok. I was staying in Kohler nearby and went to visit. When I tell you that the pastries were some of the best I ever had, including my travels to Europe! I drove back three times in four days to get more. I just got some to fly back home to Florida with. They have an amazing selection of cookies, pastries, donuts, cakes, cookies and fresh bread. Highly recommend you won’t be disappointed!"
"Johnson's Bakery seems to be a family business and looks old and traditional, I don't know the history of this bakery, but it seems like a family owned and run maybe for multiple generations. The smell driving up Superior Avenue got my attention. But once inside, I was enjoying all the smells and a friendly atmosphere. I tried not to eat too much sugar, but the cookies and desserts were too tempting, and I had to try the pastries and breads here are fresh and delicious"
"I gave the food 5/5 because well, it's hard just to say it was "Good." Because it was not good. It was GREAT. I had to get my favorite dount, a sprinkle donut. It wasn't just like a regular sprinkle donut, it was one of the best donuts I have EVER had. It was just OUTSTANDING. The vanilla frosting, perfectly spread. The sprinkles, perfectly placed with lots of fun colors. The service is also 5/5. They got to us right away, and were super kind and patient. They also got our order right. And the Atmosphere is 5/5 because of all the signs, vintage lights, and cool vintage tables and chairs."
"Great assortment of delicious bakery items. Friendly service!! We are new in town and stopped by this lovely bakery. Great friendly service and so many delicious options we had a hard time choosing! Next time we'll be getting a bag of hard rolls too."
"Every time I walk into Johnson’s bakery I feel at home. The smell of fresh bakery is astounding. Some of the workers are still there from when I was a kid and it is amazing how some things never change. I love the atmosphere and the café style inside. Very nice to remember the good ole days!!!"
Nearby Coffee Shops in Sheboygan
