"Wonderful place. They roast their own coffee fresh with so many options. BEST coffee we had in Wisconsin. What a great place, worth driving a long distance!!!!! We took home 3 different bags of coffee to grind at home."

"The brothers that run Pinky Promise are helpful, knowledgeable, and friendly. They roast their own beans, and we've purchased a few bags from time to time. Their lattes are very good. On this visit, my wife got a Cubano, which unfortunately did not meet her expectations. We thought it was supposed to be made with sweetened condensed milk, the way a typical Cuban is made, but this was mostly espresso. The espresso itself was good though."

"Coffee roasters who opened their own coffee shop. Very good coffee. Views of their roaster, opens into a studio of local artists. Very friendly owners. Baked goods available, we didn't try them. New venue opened this year."

"This is one of the worst experiences I had in a while … I had not only very expensive coffee but the lgbtq community idea is not need to be promoted in a coffee place ! The barista was dressed like a Halloween time theme … what a bad place to spend almost 8 dollars for a mocha . And iced coffee made in a cup for hot ?! What is that ?! I would never come back here . Sorry . Hope you enjoy your stole but it was pretty bad idea to be part of that ."

"Pinky Promise Coffee in Sturgeon Bay is an absolute gem! The coffee is fantastic – rich and flavorful. The space itself has a really cool and inviting vibe, making it the perfect spot to relax or catch up. To top it all off, the owners and staff are incredibly friendly and welcoming. Five stars all the way!"