"I stopped in after running the Veteran’s Day 5K downtown, expecting to grab a quick coffee and head home — but this Stone Creek location completely surprised me in the best way. I used to live on the East Side and thought I already knew Stone Creek well… but this Whitefish Bay café is on another level. The energy, the layout, the bakery selection, the buzz of people laughing and chatting — it felt like walking into a celebration of community. My coffee was perfection. My food was unique and delicious. And the people-watching? Soul-filling. Every table had a story, and it was such a joy to slow down and take it all in. Thank you, Stone Creek Coffee. The pleasure was all mine. ☕️💛"

"Stone Creek Coffee is such a great spot! The space is open and spacious with plenty of seating both inside and on the patio. I love the natural lighting—it makes it feel so welcoming and relaxing. The drinks are always delicious, and they have a wide variety of options along with tasty bakery items. Street parking is convenient, and the customer service is always super friendly. The overall ambience is warm and inviting—perfect for studying, catching up with friends, or just enjoying a good cup of coffee. Highly recommend!"

"I was very sad to see City Market go from this location, however I cannot say enough good things about the Stone Creek which has taken over. The space, both inside and out, is gorgeous. It even has a kid friendly space with mini play kitchen and a magnetic wall with varying sizes and shapes of magnets. However, I'd advise checking the menu before bringing your kids, since items are a bit more sophisticated and they don't make scrambled eggs (which seems kind of crazy to me). Counter service is friendly and quick, as is food delivery. I enjoy the reasonably sized portions and the flavor combinations in every dish. I've tried all the "Bowls" and can't pick a favorite, because they are all delectable! This place is a great addition to the community, and has become one of my go-to spots for brunch. They do offer a non-breakfast menu, however that does not start until 4:00 p.m. Something I am sure to try next!"

"Stone Creek Coffee is one of those places that just gets it. The staff is genuinely friendly and welcoming, the coffee is great, and the food options make it easy to settle in for a while. There’s plenty of space to work comfortably, whether you’re popping in for a quick work session or posting up for a little bit. And the true standout? Sparkling water on tap."

"I had the wonderful opportunity to try Stone Creek Coffee in Whitefish Bay. From the moment we walked in, we were struck by the inviting atmosphere and aesthetic of the shop, with its thoughtful layout and local artwork that really enhanced the vibe. The staff was incredibly friendly, knowledgeable about the menu, and even offered some great recommendations. My wife and I shared the stuffed bread with chorizo, the Butternut Squash Sage & Bacon sandwich, and the sausage, egg, and cheese sandwich with a side of roasted potatoes. Every bite was delicious! This spot is perfect for a cozy and tasty breakfast with friends or out-of-town family. Highly recommend!"