"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Paulie’s Fine Italian – Charleston, WV We visited Paulie’s Fine Italian on 01/17/26 and couldn’t leave such a beautiful place without a great review. From the moment we arrived, the atmosphere was upbeat, romantic, and inviting. Our table was clean and thoughtfully set, overlooking the restaurant with lovely details that made it feel special. Our waitress greeted us quickly with water and bread simple, fresh, and perfectly paired with the dipping oil. We started with the cheese curds, which were hot, crunchy, and delicious. I ordered an espresso martini that was beautifully sweet (thankfully vodka!) it honestly tasted like a candy bar and was perfect. My husband ordered a classic cheese and pepperoni pizza and rated it a solid 10/10. I had the Lobster & Bow Tie Pasta; the breadcrumbs on top were amazing, and the cream sauce was so good I used the bread to soak up every bit. While the portion was generous and I couldn’t finish it, I would’ve loved a bit more lobster—still a strong 9/10. I also had a lemon martini that was very strong and very good. We were in and out within an hour, had a wonderful experience, and can’t wait to come back. Highly recommend!"

"Jist an absolutely amazing experience. The service, food, and atmosphere were all top notch. There were times that I was just speechless eating my carbonara. It easily the best I've had in WV."

"We had a good dinner experience sitting out on the patio area. The service was good which you don’t always get when sitting further away from the main floor / kitchen. The food was fresh and had great flavor and blend of ingredients. I would say though the price is above average for the same caliber of restaurant."

"Good wine selection. Salad (arugula, blue cheese, walnuts, pear, could have used more pear); great short rib with polenta and green beans-tomato; very good dessert "budino." (Dark chocolate, espresso, caramel). One could skip the bread. Overall very good. Server, Chris, did a wonderful job. Reasonably priced with appropriate sized portions."

"Had an amazing experience here! The flavors were spot on, the service was friendly, and the atmosphere made the meal even better. Definitely coming back soon! Chris was an amazing server! He explained everything spot on with our food and was extremely sweet!"