"Really a great meal. All the food was delicious. Best calamari in a long time. Loved the bread with hot pepper oil and cheese (we all ate too much of that). Drinks really good too. Service was slow but I can overlook that on a very busy night. Prices were reasonable too"

"I celebrated my 36th birthday with my partner here and the staff was wonderful. They surprised me with a birthday desert free of charge. They gave me expert advice on wines and let me try them before choosing which one I wanted! I also forgot my purse and the manager waited outside with it for me to return to get it! Loved my experience."

"This is my girlfriend Gina‘s favorite restaurant in Morgantown. I didn’t post a picture of it but the dish called the “Diablo” is absolutely the best thing on the menu. They have specials every day and the seafood is also good. The dish the “Mediterranean” it’s also extremely good. We have been wanting to try the place called Cafe Oliverio’s for quite some time. It looks like they have pizza and hoagies at that one. I attached a picture of their salad and mussels, which were absolutely awesome. Literally almost every weekend we are like, “ let’s go to Oliverio’s!”. Yes, you can dress up and look nice but you can go casual and you can really go however, you want. There are people there dressed every single way you can imagine so you could come in with a hoodie or you could come in with a nice button down. There’s a patio in a bar area and a regular seating area and the building is gorgeous like an old industrial setting. Parking has two different options from a lot right out in front to a parking garage right next to it."

"Atmosphere (2/5) Oliverio’s is in a prime location along the Monongahela River, with the rail trail running behind it and a pleasant outdoor seating area that overlooks the water. From the outside, it gives the impression of an inviting, upscale spot, and the initial walk-in feels promising. The bar area is spacious, and the dining room has a mix of booths and tables with skylights that bring in natural light. However, closer inspection reveals that the restaurant needs a lot of TLC. The booths are worn and banged up, and surfaces throughout show signs of wear. The bathroom was especially disappointing — the door wouldn’t close properly, the bottom of it was black with grime, and the floor was sticky and unkempt, with the area below the urinal looking filthy. While the outdoor area was set up nicely for what seemed like an event, the interior felt neglected and in need of a deep cleaning. Service (2/5) Our server was friendly, but the overall service experience was slow and inconsistent. Breadsticks took far too long to arrive. When I ordered Italian wedding soup, the server later informed me it wasn’t ready yet and offered to have me take it home instead. I decided to wait for it, but when the soup finally arrived, it came in a cracked bowl — a crack that went from the rim all the way to the bottom. This is a serious health and safety concern that should have been caught before serving. The salad that came to the table was lackluster, with limp lettuce, a sparse presentation, and what appeared to be a questionable dark piece of produce that initially looked like a bug. Food (3/5) The food was average at best. The breadsticks were the highlight — warm, buttery, and flavorful. Unfortunately, the rest of the meal fell flat. My spaghetti and meatballs featured bland meatballs and a sauce that was overly sweet and tangy, not to my taste. The chicken parmesan came with lukewarm chicken and pasta topped with the same underwhelming sauce. Both dishes were supposed to feature a meat sauce, but I found no visible meat in mine. Overall Oliverio’s has a fantastic location and the potential to be a standout waterfront dining spot in Morgantown, but based on my visit, the restaurant needs major improvements in cleanliness, attention to detail, and food consistency. Right now, it’s hard to see how this place maintains its reputation without addressing these issues."

"We had Saturday reservations at 4:30 and were promptly seated. There is both indoor and outdoor seating. We were inside. The service overall was very good the entire time. Our server made some suggestions and we started with the Angel Hair Crab Balls and the Stuffed Banana Peppers. Both appetizers were very good - the crab balls in particular were very unique! We also had salads and soup - I liked the Caesar salad but didn’t love the wedding soup (it needed a little more flavor for my taste.) Everyone at the table really enjoyed their entrees. The chicken parm, seafood Alfredo and the trio were very good. My husband especially enjoyed the grilled scallops in the Alfredo. My dad had a grilled red snapper special that he really enjoyed as well. Next time we are in town I would not hesitate to stop back in!"