"Bought a birthday cake here for myself as a test run to see where I'd buy my little brothers in a few months, and I'm greatly disappointed. The cake was simply lackluster, no enthusiasm was placed. When I spoke on the phone, I asked if they could pipe a character, that it didn't have to even be good, just a blob of a circle and 2 lines for wings and a line for its tail (offered to pay more for it too). They said it was too difficult, so I settled for an edible image only cake. I pick up the cake, and yes, the edible image is there and really pretty, however they didn't hide any of the seem lines, once more the icing decoration was meh. I wouldn't have made this post if that was the issue. The issue was the taste. The icing was so grainy and sugary, I couldn't eat it, and the cake was oddly moist (not in a refreshing moist way) and just had a kind of sponge texture. I mean outside the texture, it's just a generic chocolate cake. But overall, I don't believe I'll be ordering from here again, which is regrettable as I've seen so many good reviews."

"TL;DR = they wanted me to pay them $30 for a 3-day-old cake after they missed the birthday and never apologized. I placed an order for a cake a few days ago for pickup today at 10:00 AM. At 10:06 the lights were still off, doors still locked, no visible movement inside. I couldn't wait any longer for the unknown possibility of them opening today. It was a fairly plain, simple & boring cake that was gonna cost $30. So I went to work, wondering if this place would call me to let me know my order was ready. They took down my name and my phone number at the time I placed the order. There were two employees present when I placed my order, and it was written down. Never got a phone call. What was the point of them taking my phone number if they weren't going to call me to either inform me that my cake was ready for pickup or that they were canceling my order? And knowing that they weren't open at the time I was scheduled to pick up, they certainly should have called me. This cake was for a birthday, and now the birthday was missed. This place won't be getting a second chance from me. Update: They called me 30min prior to closing the next day and didn't even apologize. Assuming this cake was made on Wednesday so that it could be picked up at 10am on Thursday, and knowing it was only 30 minutes prior to closing when they called me, they wanted me to come in the next day and still purchase a 3-day old cake from them @ $30 after they couldn't even bother to call me until 30.5 hours later? What kind of business expects someone to pay $30 for a 3-day-old cake when the business missed the birthday and couldn't even be bothered to call the customer within 24hrs? How rude and ridiculous."

"They've always pretty good little bakery. Everything I've had from there has been good! The only thing is that they seem to be booked up far in advance. So definitely have to plan way ahead if you want a custom order."

"So you think you can't find an amazing wedding cake that tastes better than any you have ever tasted at an amazingly affordable price? Then you haven't checked Little Stirr. We can't say enough to describe how wonderful this bakery, it's staff and wedding cakes are, the cream of the crop. Thank you so much, Little Stirr, for making our daughter's dream wedding cake. We pray you all have much success, and you will always be our goto and recommendation for amazing cakes, cup cakes, and treats."

"Your shop is amazing! I've been a customer since you were at your location on Southside Parkersburg, through now in Vienna. 20 years ago I had you do a baby shower cake for my sister, that baby is 19 now and he recently joined the Air Force. I have had a few of your cakes for my son's birthdays when he was younger, he's now 25. About 2 years ago I had you do a cake and cupcakes for my niece's gender reveal, I came in with an idea and you knocked it out of the park! Thank you for years of service and being such a wonderful local small business, I ALWAYS recommend you when a friend asks about cakes. Good luck, your work speaks for itself, your cakes are delicious, hands down the best around. Here is one of your delicious cakes you have done for my family."