"I really enjoyed this gem of a Pizza place. Been here in Cheyenne over a year and never new it existed. The Meat Lovers was my choice and Supreme was my friends. We ordered by the slice. Prices were fair and pizza was warmed up off the rack in the oven. Bottom crust was nice and cripy not burnt. Pizza was hot and best of all the cheese wasn't so heavy I did not have a mountain of grease running off my slices. I had a desert that tasted sweet. I don't know what that pastry was but tasted good. I will be back for more. This nice little restraunt was a breath of fresh air. Great staff nice enviornment. Look forward to trying more."

"Our visit to Mondellos family-owned pizza place was truly unforgettable! The warm, welcoming atmosphere made us feel right at home from the start. The food was exceptional—we savored the scrumptious spaghetti and meatballs, and the creamy vegetable soup was heartwarming. The attentive staff ensured our every need was met, and the owner’s thoughtful gesture towards my child made her day. Supporting family-owned businesses like this one is a joy, and we can’t wait to return for another delicious meal. Highly recommended!"

"It beats Olive Garden for sure. The sun room has a nice view outside. Even though the interior is more simple than what Olive Garden has, it still has that vibe where people in Cheyenne should take their dates and families to. As for the food, it truly beats Olive Garden. My favorite part of this restaurant is how on the outside, it looks ordinary at first but inside, it's homely and romantic. EDIT: I decided to try the marinated steak bites with rosemary and penned. The steak was slightly overcooked. To think this dish costs $40? I expected better. I'm sticking with appetizers and pizzas if I return here."

"⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ L’Osteria Mondello is hands down the best pizza in town! 🍕 David and his team put so much love and passion into every pizza — you can truly taste it in every bite. The crust is perfect, the toppings are always fresh, and the flavor is just unbeatable. Beyond the amazing food, David himself is one of the kindest, most generous people you’ll ever meet. Whether it’s for a family dinner, a party, or just a quick bite, L’Osteria Mondello never disappoints. Cheyenne is lucky to have a place — and a person — like this! 🙌❤️"

"First time here We had to wait for the host a bit and it wasn't clear where to wait. Once seated the host was awesome Our server was great too Our food was ok My carbanara was not exactly what I was expecting, it had too much pepper on it, and my son Alfredo and sausage was ok My hubby really liked his dish"