"Great pizza spot in Gillette. The pizza was excellent and had a great variety of options. The best part of the experience was the staff. Addie and Clay provided top-notch service, you could tell they loved the business and cared about their work. The owners are lucky to have them."

"What a Gem in Gillette, this place is incredible huge in size, took care of our party of 12, and the Pizza is absolutely incredible! I'll say definitely in my top 3 the crust and toppings were delicious and the desert pizza was out of this world!!! Highly recommend!!!"

"My teacher recommended Pizza Carrello when I asked about a good place to eat in Gillette. It wasn't very busy when we got there but was rapidly filling up when we left. Our server was excellent and when I asked what she would recommend, she suggested several pizzas and we chose A Pizza My Heart which was delicious! We also chose Herb's Heavenly Little Sins for dessert. They were absolutely amazing! I think next time I go there I will order them again. Our server was excellent as was our meal and we had a very positive experience! If you are looking for great pizza, I would recommend Pizza Carrello."

"Ordered 3 different pizzas. They were all great. Tried chicken pizza with BBQ sauce on the side because I'm not big on BBQ pizza. It was fantastic! Sauce is more vinegar based and ended up being my favorite. Place is a wide open space but only 2 tvs at the bar. I could see groups coming in for sports and staying a long while if they had more tvs to cater to that crowd. Great service too! Maybe my review is because I had a couple great beers? Definitely going back!"

"The atmosphere was a little cafeteria like. Big open space with lots of people talking. About 5 employees stood about 8 feet from us our whole meal talking and laughing yet it took 15 minutes to take our payment once server brought our check because she was service multiple tables at the same time. My meat pizza was fantastic, I loved every bite of it, crust was perfect, cheese was right on and sauce was sweet and on point. However, my wife's Margherite pizza was very bland. Tomato sauce tasted like watered down tomatoes and the mozzarella was cold and almost tasteless. 10/19/24 update. Ordered take out. Food was on time, it was hot and made perfect. Loved the experience of eating their take away while watching a movie at home!"